Effects of G forces on aerobatic pilots
|Based on FAA advisory circular 91-61 2/28/1984 by D. C. Beaudette
Because aerobatic flying subjects pilots to gravitational effects (G's) that can impair their ability to
safely operate the aircraft, pilots who engage in aerobatics, or those who would take up such activity, should understand G's and some of their physiological effects, their effect on the human body,
and their role in safe flying. Aerobatic flying demands the best of both aircraft and pilot.The aircraft must be highly maneuverable, yet tolerant of G-loads. The pilot must possess skill and physiological stamina. The major physiological effects of G-loading vary from reduced vision to loss of consciousness. To be able to cope with these effects, the pilot must understand them.
During the early years of aerobatics, no physiological effects of G-loading were reported, probably because aircraft power and speed were limited. Perhaps the first reported disturbance due to G's occurred in 1918, when the pilot of a Sopwith Triplane noted that the sky appeared to be gray (grayout) just before he fainted during a tight turn at 4.5 G's. In 1927, Jimmy Doolittle, as part of his graduate studies in aeronautical engineering at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, mounted
a recording accelerometer in a Fokker PW aircraft and logged G's during aerobatic maneuvers. He reported that in a sustained 4.7 G condition (power spiral) he began to lose his sight and, for a
short time, everything went black. He retained all faculties except sight and had no difficulty in righting the airplane.
With increased military use of aircraft, there was an increased interest in the effects of G's on pilots. U.S. Navy pilots experienced diminished vision, and sometimes lost consciousness, during pullouts from dive-bombing runs. A need to study the effects of acceleration under controlled conditions led to the development of large centrifuges in which human subjects could be exposed to G's while they attempted to perform certain flying tasks. The development of higher performance aircraft encouraged the development of strategies for combating the effects of G-forces. Nowadays, anti-G suits and muscle tensing or grunting procedures (M-1, L-1 maneuvers), etc., are used to protect the pilots and crews from these effects.
Changes in gravity pull, occurring in speeding up (acceleration) or slowing down (deceleration), are referred to as G's. For example, consider a pullup from a dive. The amount of G experienced by the
pilot depends on how vigorously the pilot pulls back on the controls and how readily the aircraft responds. Assume, however, that the pilot "pulls" +4G's; if the pilot were on scales, he or she would appear to weigh four times his or her usual weight. The G's in this case are designated with a positive (+) number because of their direction. Now, imagine a pushover at the start of a dive. The aircraft changes direction in such a way that the pilot tends to be thrown upward and outward. The pilot may have the sensation of weightlessness; indeed, if the pilot were on scales, he or she would weigh less. The notation used would be in a negative (-) numbers because of the direction of the acceleration in relation to the axes of the body.
One notational system for describing G's is based on reference to the direction of accelerations to the axes of the pilot as he sits in the cockpit (Figure 3). Fore and aft accelerations (Gx), and lateral accelerations (Gy) have little effect on our physiology and can be tolerated better than can head-to-foot acceleration (+Gz); and the reverse, foot-to-head G's (-Gz).
The main effects on Gz accelerations are upon the blood in blood vessels. The +Gz effects encountered in the pullout of a dive (Figure 1) will impel the fluid columns of blood toward the lower portions of the body; the output of blood from the heart will thus be reduced and so will the blood supply to the eyes and brain, which require a steady blood supply for normal functioning. Diminished blood flow and the consequently diminished oxygen supply to the head can lead to disturbances of vision, inability to coordinate muscular activity, and unconsciousness.
SYMPTOMS OF Gz EFFECTS
Positive Gz Effects. The +Gz induced effects may be described as follows:
(1) Grayout. There is graying of vision caused by diminished flow of blood to the eyes. Although there is no associated physical impairment, this condition should serve as a warning of a significant impairment of blood flow to the head.
(2) Blackout. Vision is completely lost. This condition results when the oxygen supply to the light-sensitive retinal cells is severely reduced. Contrary to other common usages of the term, consciousness is maintained. In blackout, some mental activity and muscle function remains, thus the occurrence of blackout warns of seriously reduced blood flow to the head and of a high risk of loss of consciousness. Note: In some centrifuge studies, 50 percent of the pilots had simultaneous blackout and loss of consciousness. Therefore, a pilot cannot rely on blackout to precede loss of consciousness.
(3) Loss of Consciousness. When the blood flow through the brain is reduced to a certain level, the pilot will lose consciousness. He or she may have jerking, convulsive movements; these have been seen in many subjects of centrifuge studies and in some pilots during actual flight. The pilot will slump in his or her seat. Possibly, the pilot will fall against the controls, causing the aircraft to enter flight configurations from which it cannot recover even if consciousness is regained. In centrifuge studies, many pilots lost (and regained) consciousness without realizing they had done so.
(4) How long does induced unconsciousness last? In a series of studies of pilots in centrifuges, the pilots were unconscious for an average of 15 seconds. Following this, there was an additional 5- to 15-second interval of disorientation. Thus, if there is loss of consciousness due to +Gz forces, there will be a 20- to 30-second (or longer) period during which the pilot is not in control of his or her aircraft.
b. Negative Gz Effects. Negative Gz is encountered when acceleration is in a foot-to-head direction, such as might be obtained during inverted flight, or during an outside loop or pushover maneuver (see Figure 2). Blood is then pushed toward the head, and the amount of blood returning from the head is
diminished, so the blood tends to stagnate, particularly in the head. Under mild conditions of -Gz forces, the pilot will feel congestion, as when standing on his or her head. Engorgement of blood vessels causes a reddening or flushing of the facial skin. Blood vessels in the eyes will become dilated. Some persons may experience a headache. A condition termed "redout" may occur. This may be due in part to congestion but may also occur when the lower eyelid, reacting to -Gz, rises to cover the pupil, so that one sees light through the eyelid.
Little is known about the effects of high -Gz on humans because -Gz accelerations have caused considerable discomfort in those studied. Aerobatic pilots have reported small hemorrhages in the eyes and skin. Harold Krier, an accomplished aerobatic pilot, wrote that if he got a pain in the top of his head while pulling -G's, he eased off on the controls to reduce the G-loading.
The blood vessels in the brain tolerate mild -Gz stresses well, but the increased blood pressure in the chest and neck causes a slowing of the heart in virtually all subjects. In a few individuals, there is such a marked slowing of the heart that there are intervals of several seconds between beats. In some people, the heart may beat irregularly after -Gz exposure. The slowing of the heart and irregularities of beats can add to the stagnation of blood in the brain. Thus, it appears that the greatest threat from -Gz is the loss of consciousness from the slowing of the heart, irregularities of the heartbeats, and stagnation of blood in the head.
Obviously, much aerobatic activity takes place without imposing any ill effects on pilots. G incapacitation may be a serious matter in some military aviation activities, but is it of concern in civil
A 32-year-old pilot was practicing for an airshow. His observer on the ground watched the aircraft
complete a Cuban 8 maneuver, make an uncontrolled descent, and crash. The pilot died. Because of the aircraft's movements and since no mechanical problems were found, the accident investigators suspected that the pilot had become incapacitated. An autopsy and toxicological tests showed no condition that might have contributed to incapacitation. However, the medical history indicated the pilot had a chronic heart condition. He had occasionally passed out when his heart underwent a change to very rapid beating. It was ruled that the most probable cause of the accident was the pilot's underlying heart condition, which had made him more susceptible to the G's of aerobatic maneuvers. He had lost consciousness and control of the aircraft.
A pilot who survived an episode of unconsciousness in flight reported the incident. As he practiced
normal inverted turns, the nose of the aircraft began to drop and outside reference was lost. He applied forward stick pressure, producing 2.1 to 2.3 negative G's. In his last conscious act he reduced power (to idle). He though he had lost consciousness for 3 to 4 seconds. Regaining consciousness, he found a nose high altitude and the G-meter needles were pointing to positive 9 and negative 2.4. Later inspection of the aircraft revealed that most of the metal ribs near the front spar of both wings were deformed and one wing spar brace was bent. Medical records revealed no condition that might have led to loss of consciousness. Had the pilot not regained consciousness in time to control the aircraft, the stated cause of the accident may well have been, "exceeded design stress limits of the aircraft."
During a practice flight, an experienced aerobatic pilot completed a series of 18 maneuvers and, after a short rest, began his "free" sequence of 23 maneuvers under the watchful eye of his ground observer, a judge of aerobatic flying. After the 19th maneuver, a three-quarter outside loop followed by 2-1/2 rolls from inverted to upright, the aircraft flew straight and level for a short time, departed from the practice box in a 45 degree nosedown attitude, and crashed. The pilot was killed. He had not responded to a radio call made just before impact. The events suggest that the pilot had become incapacitated. Post-mortem examination did not reveal preexisting disease that could be related to the accident.
In a discussion of G-induced loss of consciousness in civil pilots, Art Scholl, an outstanding aerobatic pilot told of a relevant episode. On the day of the incident he was not feeling well. He attempted a vertical 8 "the hard way," an outside loop on the top and an inside loop on the bottom. He completed the top loop and was pulling out of the bottom loop when he imagined he heard the sound of a clock alarm and he had the vague thought that there was some urgency in "getting up," that there was something important to do. When he became conscious, the aircraft was flying inverted about a mile away from the practice box. This was his only experience of unconsciousness during an aerobatic maneuver.
Other cases could be cited. Each year, there are a number of well- documented incidents in which military students or instructors experience loss of consciousness during maneuvers at 3 to 5 +Gz,
a level of acceleration frequently encountered in civil aerobatic maneuvers.
Symptom Threshold Deviation Range
Grayout 4.1G + 0.7G 2.2 to 7.1G
Blackout 4.7G + 0.8G 2.7 to 7.8G
Unconsciousness 5.4G + 0.9G 3.0 to 8.4G
A major outcome of these centrifuge studies was the demonstration of significant variations among subjects. The act of piloting an aircraft can raise the acceleration tolerance; thus, the results of some centrifuge studies during which the subject was passive may not apply directly to flight. This increased tolerance is not so great, however, that the aerobatic pilot should consider himself or herself immune to G- incapacitation.
One little-known, but important, aspect of tolerance to G's is the effect of rapid changes from +Gz to -Gz, or vice versa. Because aerobatics induce such rapid changes, tolerance to changes could be highly significant. It is known, for example, that when one is subjected to -Gz, blood-pressure receptors in the head and chest respond to the increased pressure and cause a reflex slowing of the heart (Figure 4). A rapid change to +Gz (for example, when the pilot executes a half-roll during a maneuver) would suddenly drop blood pressure in these receptors and there would be a rapid speeding up of the heart to maintain pressure; but because the reflex system requires some time to sense the need, the heart could be delayed in responding to this demand and blood flow to the brain might suddenly decrease. Because of the sudden transition, and possible delay in response of the heart, a vertical 8 with an outside loop on top (-Gz) and an inside loop on the bottom (+Gz) may be one of the most threatening of aerobatic maneuvers (Figure 5). An inability of the cardiovascular system to react to the rapid change from -Gz to +Gz was probably the basis for the loss of consciousness reported previously.
Obviously, some persons can withstand greater G's than others. Even experienced military pilots in a simulated aerial combat maneuver using anti-G procedures (M-1, L-1 maneuvers) could remain conscious only about 6 to 7 seconds. Everyone has a limit. Seasoned aerobatic pilots may represent a selected group because persons with less physiological resistance probably drop out of aerobatics before reaching the highest levels of performance. The aerobatic pilot will realize the potential hazards of G's and will seek to find the level of acceleration he or she can safely endure.
The ordinary accelerometer in an aerobatic aircraft "pegs out" at a maximum and a minimum value
and gives no indication of the duration of the G's, so that the accelerometer record has little significance as a record of physiological stress. National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) data show that a range of +8Gz to -6Gz (the limit of the accelerometer) can occur during aerobatic competition, but such values lack the time element. In one study both G's and time were recorded during four competitive sequences or airshows. The pilot experienced negative G's about half of the total time spent in the performance.
Approximately 10 percent of the time he has pulling +2Gz or more with spikes to +5.4Gz, and about 10 percent of the time he pulled -3Gz or more with spikes to -5.2Gz. In an "obligatory" outside 360-degree turn the pilot experienced -2Gz or more for 32 seconds.
The horizontal rolling 360-degree turn produced rapid and repeated G oscillations. In 28 seconds the pilot experienced 6 major G excursions: -3.4, +2.3, -3.5, +2.0, -4.0, and +2.3. The first transition from negative to positive G's was 5.7G's in 2 seconds, or approximately 2.9G's/second.
The outside-inside vertical 8 as was probably the most physiologically demanding; the pilot experienced a maximum of -5.2G's in the upper outside loop and 5 seconds later pulled +5.0 G's in the lower inside loop. This amounted to 10.2 G's in 5 seconds, or over 2G's per second for 5 seconds. Even G-tolerant pilots may have changes in vision or possibly loss of consciousness in this maneuver.
Any type of flying involves some degree of risk. The prudent pilot is familiar with the risks involved and acquires the knowledge and skills necessary for reducing these risks to a minimum. The pilot is also aware of his or her own limitations and can make accurate judgments of his or her ability to withstand the stresses of flight. As noted here, the susceptibility to acceleration is an especially important limitation of the aerobatic pilot, and to recognize and understand this limitation is important to safe aerobatic flying. Listed below are some suggestions for minimizing the hazards of acceleration in this type of flying:
a. If you are just beginning in aerobatics, fly with an instructor. Take advantage of the instructor's experience and knowledge.
b. Ask the instructor to familiarize you with the "feel" of various maneuvers, not only the rapid executions expertly done, but the hesitant, sluggish ones you will be doing in your early practice. Remember that the rate of onset of acceleration is an important factor that you must learn to appreciate.
c. If you experience dimming or graying in vision during flight, realize that this represents diminished blood flow through the eyes and that you may be close to your tolerance limit. Ease off on the controls to reduce the G-load.
d. If you experience incapacitation or have any lingering symptoms as a result of aerobatics, consult a knowledgeable flight surgeon before you resume flying. Some people may be unusually susceptible to G-loading. If you are one of these, you need to know about it; you may not be so lucky the next time.
e. Frequent exposure to G-stress may "tune" the human system, making it less sensitive to higher G-loads. If you have not flown aerobatics for some time, begin with the simpler, less stressful maneuvers when you take it up again.
f. Physical conditioning does not seem to increase tolerance to G-loads; marathon running lowers tolerance. On the other hand, a well-tuned cardiovascular system seems to recover more rapidly from many different kinds of stress. Keep in shape.
g. Be especially mindful of your current physical condition. Do you really "feel" like aerobatics today? If you don't feel well, wait until you do. Consult a physician if you have any doubts about your health.
h. Be careful of what, and how, you eat. Adequate exercise and diet help to maintain your blood sugar at normal levels. A low level of blood sugar can make you very sensitive to G-loading. Remember that after a high carbohydrate meal (e.g., pancakes and syrup, or candy bars), the blood sugar will fall in about an hour, sometimes quicker, so avoid such meals. Eat well balanced, light meals before flying. A large meal could cause pooling of the blood in the digestive tract and decrease G- tolerance by reducing the amount of blood available to the general circulation.
i. Be aware that if you are accustomed to flying in a coastal region and then undertake the same aerobatics at a region of higher altitude, such as Denver, Colorado, you will have a lowered tolerance to G's. The oxygen content of the blood if lowered by exposure to the higher altitude, and the oxygen supply to the brain might be reduced to critical levels during +Gz loading.
j. Remember that anything that reduces blood volume or cardiovascular response may reduce G-tolerance. Dehydration, excessive sweating, severe sunburn, low blood pressure, prolonged
standing or sitting, hypoxia, infection (even minor illnesses), and medications all lower G-tolerance. Alcohol and hangovers will reduce your ability to perform aerobatic maneuvers. Make sure you are as fit as your aircraft.
Aerobatic flying is a beautiful coordination of pilot and aircraft. It requires a well- engineered aircraft and a highly-skilled pilot. Many pilots believe the restricting factors in aerobatics to be the load limits of the aircraft. For the exceptional pilot this may be so, but for some it is the ability of the pilot to withstand the
accelerations of the maneuvers. The truly skilled pilot will know his or her limitations, will train to extend them, and will avoid conditions that lower tolerance and jeopardize safety.